jkisolo.com

A Vision for a Revitalized Research Community

Written on

Chapter 1: The Current State of Research

The research landscape today is marred by various systemic issues, including rigid academia structures, limited funding opportunities, and stringent publication deadlines. These factors contribute to a stagnant environment where innovation is scarce, and research often lacks originality. In light of this, let's envision an ideal research society.

Scenario I: Collaborative Problem Solving

Bob is eager to tackle research challenges and recently discovered a significant answer worth sharing. However, he recognizes some limitations in his approach and is uncertain about how to address them. In this ideal research community, Bob can easily document his findings and post them on arXiv, along with highlighting the unresolved issues as open problems. Alice, who specializes in the same area, receives a notification about Bob's post and finds it intriguing. She then contributes her solution to one of the open issues on arXivOP. Bob, appreciating Alice's insights, incorporates her solution into his work and credits her as a co-author.

arXivOP serves as a dynamic platform connecting researchers through open problems. Authors can submit unresolved issues either to seek collaboration or to critique others' research. Mimicking the user experience of platforms like StackOverflow, anyone can propose solutions for open problems, which the community can evaluate based on accuracy. Subsequent protocols allow for the merging of original articles with accepted solutions.

Scenario II: Building Reputation Through Engagement

Alice reviews Bob's work and identifies an open problem, which she submits on arXivOP, thereby gaining recognition. Upon being notified, Bob can express his eagerness for a solution by marking the issue as "committed," indicating that he will include the contributors' names in the list of authors if he decides to enhance his article with one of their solutions. This approach encourages greater community involvement. Later, Carol discovers a solution and earns her own reputation. Bob can then either add Carol as a co-author, if the problem was committed, or acknowledge her contribution without co-authorship.

Holacratic Contribution Recognition

Now that we've established a system for fostering researcher connections, we must address another significant challenge: quantifying contributions and determining author order. The difficulty lies in comparing the significance of various types of contributions. arXivOP resolves this by defining specific roles for contributions.

In this system, both papers and solutions are categorized by contribution roles, with authors' names listed alphabetically under each role. This resembles the holacratic model of organization—neither hierarchical nor flat—where different roles such as Hypothesis, Proof, Experiment, and Support exist, allowing individuals to contribute in diverse ways.

Understanding Problems and Solutions

Conceptually, we can distinguish between two domains: problems and solutions. Papers and solutions to open problems fall within the solution domain, while open problems or reviews belong to the problem domain. Each problem originates from a paper or solution, and each solution is a response to an open problem. This relationship can be illustrated through a bipartite graph:

Bipartite graph illustrating problem-solution relationships

Designing the Framework

To visualize these concepts, I've sketched out rough representations of problems and solutions. In the first figure, a problem raised by user D appears on the left, with corresponding solutions on the right. Bob, the corresponding author of the source paper (or solution), can commit to this problem by clicking S on the left.

Open Problem page interface

The second illustration depicts a solution contributed by users A, B, and C, each assigned specific roles. Three open problems stemming from this solution are also represented, and by clicking P on the left, the parent problem can be accessed.

Solution page interface with role assignments

Closing Thoughts

I acknowledge that many challenges still lie ahead on the path to this envisioned reality. For instance, we might consider implementing handshake protocols to account for the long-term nature of research, and each problem could feature a list of potential solutions. Additionally, university resources could be made available through faculty members who take on support roles in research papers. While this vision may seem distant, I believe that with collective effort, we can move closer to achieving it.

Chapter 2: Scientific Utopia: Improving Openness and Reproducibility in Scientific Research

This video discusses the importance of enhancing openness and reproducibility in scientific research, aiming to create a more collaborative environment.

Chapter 3: Utopia - Research Showcase 1

In this video, various innovative research projects are highlighted, showcasing the potential of a reimagined research community.

Share the page:

Twitter Facebook Reddit LinkIn

-----------------------

Recent Post:

Unlocking Your Full Potential: A Guide to Empathetic Communication

Explore the art of empathetic communication to enhance relationships and foster deeper connections.

Mastering Feature Flags in Django: A Comprehensive Guide

Explore the essential techniques for managing feature flags in Django applications to enhance development and deployment strategies.

Does Failure Truly Exist? A Deep Dive into Our Fears

Exploring the concept of failure and its impact on our lives, along with insights from influential speakers.

Philosophy: A Path to Intentional Living in a Fast-Paced World

Explore how philosophy fosters intentional living amidst the rush of modern life.

Reevaluating Human Exercise Needs in a Modern Context

This article explores the evolutionary basis for exercise, emphasizing its importance for human health in our modern sedentary lifestyle.

Exploring Alternative Income Sources Beyond Medium Writing

Discover alternative platforms for writers to earn between $50 to $300 per post, alleviating concerns about Medium's viability.

# Rethinking Innovation: Why Lightbulb Moments Aren't the Answer

Explore why relying on sudden insights for innovation is misguided and how consistent effort leads to true creativity.

Mastering Social Media: A Freelancer's Guide to Success

Discover effective strategies for leveraging social media to enhance your freelance business and attract clients.