Understanding Manipulation in Religious Upbringing
Written on
Chapter 1: The Nature of Manipulation in Faith-Based Parenting
In the realm of religious upbringing, manipulation can manifest through the teachings imparted by parents. Unlike standard parental guidance, certain families leverage religious doctrine as a tool for control. My personal journey through a religious household marked by addiction and codependency has illuminated the potential for such manipulation in religious teachings.
The narrative that follows offers insights drawn from my experiences with triangulation in religious contexts and my ongoing struggle with its effects. The reflections shared here are purely personal, the result of my own battles and the self-help strategies I devised while navigating the rocky path toward healing from manipulation.
I hold a strong belief in God, but my faith has become far more enriching as I learn to distinguish the genuine from the manipulative. Triangulation, in this context, is a tactic where a third party is invoked to sway or control a situation or relationship.
This technique can be one of the most harmful forms of abuse that parents might inflict on their children. It can occur either unconsciously, where parents genuinely believe they are acting in the best interest of their child, or consciously, where they intentionally seek to dominate the child's emotions and future.
Through triangulation, information is relayed via an intermediary, influencing a child's understanding or providing an advantage to the manipulator. This intermediary could be a sibling, another parent, or even a friend. The child often remains unaware of the true motives behind these messages, which may include falsehoods or misrepresentations.
In monotheistic religions, triangulation might involve God or the devil acting as a "third party" in the parent-child dynamic. Parents might teach their children that God has specific expectations of them, or that the devil is watching, ready to pounce on any misstep. When manipulation is consciously intended, the child lacks the resources to verify these beliefs, leading them to trust their family implicitly.
When a child's parents set expectations, it can be challenging enough. However, the pressure intensifies when they are told that an unseen deity demands certain behaviors, with the threat of lifelong punishment or lack of blessings looming over them.
The difficulty arises from the distorted connection that can develop between the child and this perceived 'third party,' mediated by the parent or authority figure. For instance, I was often taught to always forgive wrongdoings, including those by family members, under the guise that it was God's expectation. If I attempted to address any grievances, the discussion would often be stifled by invoking God's authority.
Section 1.1: The Role of Forgiveness in Manipulation
A sound individual would take responsibility for their actions, including parents and educators. Yet, numerous religious communities promote the idea of merely “forgiving” instances of abuse, attributing the wrongdoing to the devil's influence and absolving the individual of accountability. This is a clear form of manipulation.
Parents inherently mold their children's thoughts and beliefs, striving to pass on wisdom and experiences through generations. However, psychological research indicates that maturity often requires discarding some of these childhood teachings. James Hollis, a noted Jungian analyst, articulates this journey as gaining personal authority over inherited beliefs and having the courage to live consistently with that authority.
As children grow, they need to question previous beliefs, especially in religious contexts where God is seen as a third party. This complicates the process, as true devotion to God can make it nearly impossible to relinquish early teachings that later seem harmful.
For more in-depth insights into the beliefs I've had to navigate and shed, refer to my essay titled "Pulling Masks Off Religious Fallacies," which delves into this challenging process.
Section 1.2: The Concept of Salvation and Its Implications
The church has historically wielded triangulation as a means of control, employing figures like the Pope to speak on behalf of God. While many who claim to hear God's voice genuinely seek to enrich humanity, there are those whose intentions are to manipulate behavior for personal gain, whether financial or intellectual.
The doctrine of soul salvation is central to many monotheistic beliefs, particularly in Christianity, where the idea stems from the concept of original sin. This teaching can provide hope and serve as a turning point for many individuals, especially those who have faced abuse. However, introducing such concepts to children demands caution, as they can easily become tools for manipulation and guilt.
Many of my friends who grew up in strict religious environments grapple with guilt and shame stemming from their upbringing, where innocent childhood actions were deemed sinful. This raises the critical question of whether such teachings are beneficial for children, given their potential to significantly affect emotional health and self-worth.
Ultimately, while our emotions and intuitions are palpable, the essence of our souls remains intangible. No human can guarantee another's salvation, even on God's behalf. Yet, many sermons promise salvation contingent on specific actions, which is a manipulative tactic that exploits fear and dependency on intermediaries.
The image of the devil serves as a powerful method of control, particularly over children. When they are indoctrinated with the belief that a malevolent force is always lurking, it becomes easy to manipulate their thoughts and actions through fear. Such teachings can result in a profound sense of victimhood, as life's challenges are seen as attacks rather than opportunities for growth.
In my upbringing, I was frequently told, “Forgive them; it’s not them, but the devil at work.” This leaves individuals feeling trapped with limited options and a lack of constructive pathways forward.
Chapter 2: The Consequences of Religious Manipulation
The teachings surrounding the devil can stifle personal growth and perpetuate emotional blockages. Children may find themselves unable to process feelings like anger or hurt, which can lead to a lifetime of confusion. Furthermore, they may come to view challenges as devilish attacks rather than chances for personal development.
It is crucial to shield children from such damaging ideas. There is a wealth of beneficial lessons available in both religious and secular literature that encourage exploration and positive engagement with the world.
The continuous repetition of certain teachings can also restrict a child's mental and emotional development. Young minds are impressionable, and when they are constantly fed the same doctrine, it limits their worldview. In many strict religious environments, literature and philosophies outside their tradition are demonized, further constraining their growth.
In closing, while parents play a significant role in shaping their children's values, it is essential that this does not impede their emotional, spiritual, and intellectual well-being. The Christian faith has contributed greatly to our understanding of human rights and ethical principles. Children should be encouraged to explore diverse perspectives and engage with the world in meaningful ways.
The process of healing from restrictive teachings can be arduous, but it is vital for personal and societal growth. As we strive to eliminate harmful practices from our cultural fabric, we move closer to achieving greater freedom and understanding.
I invite you to share your thoughts on the role of salvation teachings and any experiences you may have had related to this topic. Open dialogue is essential as we navigate these complex issues together.