Survey Design Essentials: Best Practices for Insightful Results
Written on
Welcome to the inaugural installment of a four-part series dedicated to outstanding survey design!
In this series, we will delve into best practices for developing effective surveys, focusing on how to formulate questions that are straightforward, succinct, and stimulate thoughtful answers. By leveraging recent research and industry standards, we aim to equip you with actionable advice and techniques for designing surveys that yield meaningful insights. This series caters to bloggers, marketers, and researchers alike, all eager to enhance their survey design capabilities and produce insightful outcomes.
“My fascination with human behavior began years ago when I aimed to create a systems dynamics model of social behavior, heavily influenced by Jung’s innovative work on Psychological Types.”
As a consultant in data science and analytics, my expertise encompasses a wide array of fields, such as behavioral typology, customer analytics, emotional analysis, sentiment modeling, campaign management, public relations, brand development, and political research (the current climate is ripe with affective polarization, indeed!).
Years ago, my quest to comprehend human behavior led me to design a systems dynamics model of social behavior, which was significantly shaped by Jung’s influential research on Psychological Types. This journey steered me towards computational social science, particularly psychometrics, as I sought to utilize data to unravel the complexities of human behavior.
A pivotal resource in my journey has been “The Psychology of Survey Response” by Roger Tourangeau, Lance J. Rips, and Kenneth Rasinski. I discovered this remarkable book during a caffeine-fueled visit to The Harvard Bookstore in Cambridge, MA, nearly two decades ago, and its insights have profoundly impacted both my personal and professional life. This series will heavily reference the concepts discussed in this book, targeting social science professionals, survey designers, psychology experts, psychometric analysts, and anyone interested in crafting more effective questionnaires. We will dissect major themes from the book, exploring best practices and guidelines for creating surveys that yield meaningful insights into human experience.
Our primary objective will be to emphasize the fundamental aspects of survey design rather than dive into specific analytical methodologies. We will guide you through crucial steps, such as narrowing the focus of open-ended questions and striking a balance between open-ended and closed-ended questions for depth and breadth of responses. By the conclusion of this series, you'll be adept at the art of survey writing, enabling you to create surveys that genuinely matter and elevate your research.
I hope the insights and best practices shared here will enhance your survey writing skills. Equipped with these strategies, you’ll unlock the potential of effective question design and learn how to ask questions that yield high-value responses, providing you with insights that significantly impact your work. Stay tuned and prepare to harness the power of effective question design for enlightening insights and impactful results.
# Part One Mastering the Fundamentals: Best Practices for Crafting Effective Surveys --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
In this section, we will examine the core principles of survey design, including how to formulate clear and focused questions that generate high-quality responses. Learn to sidestep common pitfalls and ensure your survey questions are meticulously crafted for maximum insights and results.
Let’s dive straight into our first topic:
Narrow the Scope of Open-Ended Questions to a Single Topic
Survey design is a vital aspect of any research initiative, particularly when it comes to crafting open-ended questions that produce valuable insights. A frequent mistake made by researchers is to ask multiple questions or touch on several topics within a single open-ended question.
According to “The Psychology of Survey Response,” limiting the scope of open-ended questions to one topic is crucial for effective survey design. By doing this, researchers allow respondents to concentrate on a specific matter, which often results in more thoughtful and detailed replies.
As Tourangeau and colleagues note, “when a question encompasses multiple subjects, respondents may selectively answer or fixate on just one aspect, leading to an incomplete or misleading portrayal.”
Consider a survey that inquires about a respondent's dining experience at a restaurant, accompanied by an open-ended question that spans everything from food quality to service and ambiance. This broad question may yield incomplete or superficial responses.
“…when a question covers multiple topics, respondents may answer selectively or focus on only one aspect, providing an incomplete or misleading picture.”
A more effective strategy would be to break the inquiry into smaller, more focused questions. For instance, separate questions could address food, service, and ambiance individually. This method allows respondents to direct their attention to one aspect at a time, yielding more detailed and valuable insights.
Don A. Dillman, a leading survey researcher, emphasizes that “Questions that are overly general and encompass too many topics are challenging for respondents to answer comprehensively.”
Key Takeaways:
- Narrowing the scope of open-ended questions to a single issue is essential for effective survey design.
- Questions that cover multiple topics may lead to incomplete or misleading responses.
- Segmenting questions into smaller, more specific topics can result in more detailed insights from respondents.
Avoid Vague or Ambiguous Questions
When constructing surveys, it’s essential to steer clear of vague or ambiguous questions. Vague questions lack precision, while ambiguous ones are open to multiple interpretations. As outlined by Tourangeau et al., utilizing clear and concise language is vital to avoid these pitfalls. Additionally, it’s crucial to consider how the mode of administration may influence respondents’ comprehension of the questions.
Mode of administration pertains to how the survey is conducted, whether online, by phone, or in-person. Different methods can affect how respondents interpret questions, a concept we will explore further in this series.
“Ensuring that survey questions are clear and unambiguous is vital for obtaining accurate and meaningful responses.”
Employing clear language and considering the administration mode can lead to more precise and reliable survey responses. Tourangeau and colleagues also suggest using concrete examples to clarify question meanings. By following these best practices, survey designers can create questions that are easily understood, resulting in accurate and meaningful responses.
Here are some examples of vague or ambiguous questions:
- “How satisfied are you with our product?”
This question is overly vague and could be interpreted in various ways. Is the respondent referring to overall satisfaction, satisfaction with a specific feature, or something else entirely? Without clarification, responses will likely be unreliable and challenging to analyze. A more specific version could be: “How satisfied are you with the ease of use of our product?”
- “Do you own a car?”
This question is ambiguous as it doesn’t specify what constitutes a “car.” Does it refer solely to personal vehicles, or does it include work vehicles as well? What about motorcycles? To clarify, you could rephrase it as: “Do you own a personal car for transportation?”
- “How often do you exercise?”
This question is vague since it doesn’t define what “exercise” entails. Does it refer only to structured workouts, or does it include activities like walking, gardening, or sports? To improve clarity, consider specifying the activities you want respondents to contemplate: “How often do you engage in moderate-intensity physical activities, such as brisk walking or gardening?”
In addition to using clear language and providing examples, it's important to consider the administration mode when designing survey questions. The presentation of questions can influence how respondents understand them, potentially reducing ambiguity.
In summary, avoiding vague or ambiguous questions is crucial for generating surveys that yield accurate and insightful responses. By being specific, using clear language, and considering the mode of administration, survey designers can craft questions that are easily understood and provide reliable data.
Use Simple and Clear Language
Survey design is an art that requires a careful balance of creating questions that are both comprehensive and approachable. A critical element often overlooked, yet significantly affecting the quality of survey responses, is the language used in the questions. According to experts in survey methodology, employing simple and clear language is essential for ensuring that surveys effectively elicit meaningful insights from respondents.
Dr. John Johnson, a prominent figure in survey methodology, underscores the importance of language in survey design. He states, “Survey questions should be framed in a manner that is easily understood by all respondents, regardless of their educational background. Utilizing jargon or technical terms can confuse respondents and lead to inaccurate or incomplete answers.” In essence, survey questions should be accessible to everyone, irrespective of their expertise in the subject matter.
“Using plain language helps to eliminate barriers and ensures that everyone has an equal opportunity to participate in the survey and provide their valuable insights.”
Dr. Sunghee Lee, another leading researcher in survey methodology, echoes this sentiment by stating, “Clear language is the cornerstone of effective survey design. It guarantees that respondents fully grasp the questions posed and can provide accurate and thoughtful answers.” When language is simple, the potential for misinterpretation diminishes, allowing respondents to offer more reliable and meaningful responses.
Dr. Michael Chen, an experienced survey researcher, emphasizes that using simple, clear language not only enhances response quality but also fosters inclusivity. He notes, “As researchers, we must ensure that our surveys are accessible to everyone, regardless of their background or literacy level. Plain language helps eliminate barriers and guarantees equal opportunities for participation.”
Key Takeaways:
- Clarity is paramount: Utilizing simple and clear language in survey questions is crucial for ensuring respondents understand the questions, leading to accurate and meaningful responses.
- Avoid jargon and technical terms: Employing industry-specific language can confuse respondents, resulting in incomplete or inaccurate answers. Language should be easily comprehensible to all.
- Promote inclusivity: Using plain language helps eliminate barriers, ensuring that all individuals can participate and share their valuable insights.
The significance of simplicity cannot be overstated in survey design. Employing clear language in survey questions is a foundational best practice that enhances response quality, fosters inclusivity, and ensures that surveys effectively capture meaningful insights. By prioritizing simplicity in language, researchers can create surveys that are more approachable, engaging, and yield accurate, valuable data.
Use Concrete Examples or Scenarios to Illustrate the Question
In crafting survey questions, one effective best practice is to incorporate concrete examples or scenarios. This approach not only clarifies the question for the respondent but also enhances the likelihood of obtaining accurate, meaningful responses.
But what exactly are concrete examples or scenarios? They involve providing specific, relatable situations that give context to the question, making it more relevant to the respondent's experiences.
Dr. Floyd J. Fowler Jr., an expert in survey research, states, “Including a brief example in the question can significantly enhance clarity and reduce respondent error.” This sentiment is echoed by other survey methodology authorities, such as Dr. Jon Krosnick, who emphasizes the importance of “making questions as clear and concrete as possible.”
“Incorporating a concrete example or scenario helps eliminate ambiguity or vagueness from the question, making it easier for respondents to provide accurate and meaningful answers.”
So, why is utilizing concrete examples or scenarios so effective in survey design? Here are a few reasons:
Enhances Clarity: Concrete examples help clarify the question's meaning for the respondent. By providing a relatable real-world scenario, they can better understand what is being asked.
For instance, instead of asking “How often do you exercise?”, a more contextualized version could be, “In the past week, how many times did you engage in physical activity for at least 30 minutes, such as running or lifting weights?”
Reduces Ambiguity: Concrete examples can also lessen ambiguity in the question. By providing specific details, respondents are less likely to feel confused or uncertain about what is being asked.
Dr. Fowler explains, “Including a concrete example helps eliminate vagueness, making it easier for respondents to give accurate and meaningful answers.” Dr. Krosnick adds, “Individuals are more inclined to respond to questions relevant to their lives. By employing concrete examples or scenarios, we make survey questions more personally meaningful, which can enhance response rates and data quality.”
In conclusion, utilizing concrete examples or scenarios is a potent tool in survey design that can improve clarity, reduce ambiguity, and increase relevance for respondents. By providing relatable real-world situations, we can craft survey questions that yield more accurate and meaningful responses.
Key Takeaways:
- Using concrete examples or scenarios can greatly enhance the clarity and accuracy of survey questions.
- Concrete examples help reduce ambiguity, facilitating respondents in providing meaningful answers.
- By increasing relevance, concrete examples can improve response rates and data quality.
Avoid Leading or Biased Questions
When designing surveys, it’s crucial to recognize that numerous biases can potentially skew results. While we can't cover them all, it's vital to focus on some of the most common biases that could distort survey findings. Leading or biased questions can unduly influence responses, making it imperative for survey designers to be vigilant in identifying and avoiding these pitfalls.
Sampling bias occurs when the sample population fails to represent the target population, leading to skewed results. This can arise from non-random sample selection or systematically excluding certain groups.
Dr. Andrew Gelman, a professor at Columbia University, states, “Sampling bias is among the most prevalent and problematic issues in survey research. If the sample isn’t representative, the results may not be generalizable to the broader population.”
Nonresponse bias occurs when a significant portion of the selected sample does not respond, resulting in an unrepresentative sample. This can happen if certain demographics are more inclined to respond than others or if survey design leads to lower response rates.
Dr. Don A. Dillman warns, “Nonresponse bias is increasingly concerning in survey research, especially with the rise of online surveys. High nonresponse rates can result in distorted outcomes, making accurate conclusions challenging.”
Response bias refers to instances where respondents provide inaccurate or dishonest answers, often influenced by social pressures or a desire to present themselves favorably.
Dr. Paul Beatty emphasizes, “Response bias can significantly affect survey results, particularly concerning sensitive topics. Researchers should ensure anonymity or employ indirect questioning techniques to minimize its impact.”
Acquiescence bias occurs when respondents are more prone to agree with statements than disagree, irrespective of their true opinions.
Dr. Elizabeth Martin explains, “Acquiescence bias is common, especially in Likert-type scales. Careful question wording and incorporating reverse-worded items can help mitigate this bias.”
Extreme response bias occurs when respondents favor the most extreme options, such as “strongly agree” or “strongly disagree,” regardless of their actual opinions.
Dr. Frauke Kreuter states, “Extreme response bias can lead to distorted results, particularly in Likert-type scales. Researchers must be aware of this bias and use balanced response options to reduce its effect.”
Social desirability bias occurs when respondents provide answers they believe are more socially acceptable rather than their true feelings.
Dr. Roger Tourangeau highlights, “Social desirability bias can significantly affect survey outcomes, especially regarding sensitive issues. Designers must consider this bias and implement strategies to mitigate its effects.”
Order effect occurs when the sequence of questions influences responses. Dr. Norbert Schwarz states, “The order in which questions are asked can greatly affect survey results. Researchers must carefully consider question sequencing to minimize order effects.”
Framing effect refers to how question phrasing can influence responses. Dr. Amos Tversky asserts, “The framing of a question can significantly impact responses. Designers should avoid leading language that may sway answers.”
To prevent biased questions, survey designers should remain vigilant about potential biases and take steps to mitigate them. A key strategy, which we will elaborate on later in the series, is to pilot test the survey with a small group to identify any issues with question wording or order. Consulting subject matter experts and relevant literature can further ensure questions are framed objectively.
The main takeaway is that avoiding leading or biased questions is essential for yielding accurate, meaningful survey results. By being mindful of these biases and actively working to mitigate them, designers can produce effective, informative surveys.
Provide Clear Instructions for Answering Questions
Providing explicit instructions on how to answer survey questions is crucial for obtaining high-quality responses. This involves giving precise guidance on the types of responses desired, response length, and any other relevant instructions to aid respondents in providing the most valuable feedback.
Roger Tourangeau and colleagues emphasize that clear instructions are vital for surveys that generate insightful data. They state, “Instructions that are overly general can create confusion for respondents, leading to variability in the data.”
“Providing clear instructions can help you get more accurate and consistent data, and can also enhance response rates.”
Here are some best practices to consider for providing clear instructions:
- Be specific about the desired response types. For instance, if asking an open-ended question, indicate whether a brief or detailed response is expected.
- Offer examples or prompts to guide respondents in their answers. As Tourangeau et al. explain, “Examples can be particularly valuable for open-ended questions, offering respondents a clear model for their responses.”
- Utilize clear, simple language that is easy to understand. Avoid jargon or technical terms that could confuse respondents.
By adhering to these practices, you can enhance the quality of feedback from survey respondents. Christina Petersen, a research consultant, notes, “Providing clear instructions can lead to more accurate data and improve overall survey response rates.”
For example, in a customer satisfaction survey, clear instructions regarding the expected responses can ensure that feedback is actionable. This, in turn, can guide product development and enhance customer satisfaction over time.
“The main thing is to use language that is not too technical, that doesn’t contain a lot of jargon, and that the average person would be able to understand.” - Dr. Mick Couper
In another scenario, when surveying employee engagement, clear instructions can help ensure that all employees provide consistent, relevant feedback, ultimately informing HR policies and enhancing employee satisfaction.
Key Takeaway: Providing clear instructions is pivotal for crafting surveys that yield insightful data. By specifying desired response types, offering examples or prompts, and employing clear language, you can ensure high-quality feedback that drives informed decision-making and business success.
Use a Conversational Style to Encourage Detailed Responses
Effective survey design not only hinges on the questions asked but also on how they are presented. A key element is the language and tone used throughout the survey. According to “The Book,” employing a conversational style that invites detailed, thoughtful responses can lead to higher-quality data.
But what does a conversational style entail? The authors suggest utilizing “simple and clear” language alongside concrete examples to elucidate questions, while avoiding leading or biased inquiries and providing clear answering instructions.
Dr. Mick Couper emphasizes the significance of employing familiar language. He states, “The main thing is to use language that is not too technical and that the average person can easily understand.”
A conversational tone can also foster rapport between the surveyor and the respondent, promoting more thoughtful and detailed responses. Dr. Krista Gile explains that “respondents are more inclined to provide thoughtful answers when they sense the surveyor values their opinions and takes their responses seriously.”
“Using a more conversational style can help establish a connection with the respondent, encouraging them to share more detailed and thoughtful responses.”
Survey designers should focus on using language that is clear and relatable, providing concrete examples, and building rapport through a conversational tone. By implementing these strategies, survey designers can inspire more thoughtful and detailed responses, ultimately leading to richer data and insights.
For instance, a customer satisfaction survey conducted in formal, impersonal language may inhibit respondents from freely expressing their opinions. Conversely, a conversational approach can foster a connection, prompting respondents to provide more detailed feedback.
Similarly, in political polling, a pollster using a conversational tone may elicit more honest and detailed responses from individuals hesitant to share their political views with strangers.
Overall, adopting a conversational style in survey design can yield more meaningful insights and higher-quality data. As Dr. Couper notes, “It’s all about building trust with the respondent, making them feel comfortable and valued, and eliciting their honest and thoughtful responses.”
Avoid Requesting Information That Respondents May Not Provide
In survey design, a significant challenge is obtaining accurate and honest information from respondents. Questions that are overly personal, sensitive, or difficult to answer can result in incomplete or misleading data. To mitigate this issue, it’s crucial to be mindful of the questions posed and ensure respondents feel comfortable and confident in their responses.
Tourangeau et al. stress the importance of avoiding requests for information that respondents may be unwilling or unable to provide, particularly sensitive or personal inquiries. As they state, “The fundamental principle of survey design is that respondents must be able to furnish the requested information.”
One way to navigate this is by employing indirect questioning techniques. Dr. Alka Chandna suggests, “Indirect questioning allows for asking sensitive questions in a less direct manner, helping respondents feel more at ease.” For example, instead of asking “Do you have a history of mental illness?”, a more indirect approach could be “Have you ever received treatment for a mental health condition?”
Additionally, incorporating skip patterns enables the survey to bypass irrelevant questions for certain respondents. For example, if a question pertains to income but the respondent is unemployed, the survey should skip to the next relevant question.
“…instead of asking ‘Do you have a history of mental illness?’ a more indirect approach would be to ask ‘Have you ever received treatment for a mental health condition?’”
Providing a “prefer not to answer” option also allows respondents to opt-out of uncomfortable questions without feeling pressured. Tourangeau and colleagues highlight the importance of providing space for respondents to indicate uncertainty or lack of knowledge about a question.
In summary, to avoid requesting information that respondents may not be willing or able to provide, survey designers should be mindful of question types, employ indirect questioning techniques, utilize skip patterns, and offer a “prefer not to answer” option. By taking these steps, designers can ensure respondents feel comfortable providing accurate and honest information, resulting in more meaningful, actionable survey data.
Conclusion
As we conclude this first segment of our limited series on survey design, we hope you feel motivated to elevate your survey design skills. We’ve focused on mastering the fundamentals of survey design, discussing best practices for crafting effective questions that yield high-value responses. We’ve highlighted the significance of clear, focused questions and how to avoid common pitfalls that can hinder your survey results.
However, our journey is just beginning. In the next installment, titled “Crafting the Perfect Question: Strategies for Effective Survey Design,” we will delve deeper into the intricacies of question structure and design. Drawing from current research and industry standards, we will provide practical tips and strategies for designing questions that encourage thoughtful responses and deliver meaningful insights.
As we continue this journey together, we hope you will be inspired to unlock the full potential of effective question design for revealing insights and achieving impactful results for your organization’s analytical needs. Stay tuned for the next chapter in our series, and let’s elevate our survey design skills together!
Final Note:
If you value the insights provided in this content, consider subscribing to my Medium page, sharing it with others, and if you found this article beneficial, I invite you to support my efforts directly through membership, purchasing a cup of coffee, or making a small donation. Your generous contributions serve as a significant encouragement for me to continue delivering more insightful and engaging material. Together, let’s sustain this positive exchange and foster an environment where our shared pursuit of knowledge and enjoyment can thrive.
