The Surprising Economics Behind Dog Ownership and Its Impact
Written on
If you take a stroll through the woods today, you might be surprised. Those sticks scattered on the ground? They retail for £3 at Pets At Home.
What was once a hobby for devoted elderly individuals has transformed into a thriving billion-dollar industry, attracting the attention of hedge funds worth trillions and appealing to all age groups.
Welcome to the extravagant realm of pampered pets.
This wasn’t always the case; older generations might recall a time when taking a dog behind the shed for a quick check-up was standard practice, with veterinary care being a rare luxury.
Today, however, the modern pet, from the finest Yaks Milk chews to comprehensive care, constitutes one of the fastest-expanding markets of the 2020s.
In essence, contemporary entrepreneurs have tapped into a necessity that we can't seem to live without.
Financial analysis reveals staggering figures in the dog care market. Celebrity dog trainer Cesar Millan offers a 9-day intensive training course for a staggering $11,290.
At least dog training is a traditional service, dating back to the domestication of wolves in China around 4,000 years ago. Indeed, investing six figures in police dogs is justifiable due to their unique capabilities.
> A dog’s olfactory sense is extraordinary; as National Geographic highlights, the portion of a dog’s brain dedicated to smell is 40 times larger than that of humans. This ability extends well beyond law enforcement, with a 2019 study indicating trained dogs can achieve a 97% success rate in detecting cancer.
However, the rising costs of pet insurance are alarming, with projections estimating the market will reach $19.5 billion by 2028—tripling in just eight years.
Not only are insurance premiums increasing, but the scope of coverage is also shifting, with many genetic conditions being excluded, affecting breeds from French Bulldogs with breathing issues to the massive Bernese Mountain Dogs.
Reports of exorbitant vet bills are becoming commonplace—$68,000 for a single elderly Great Dane is just one of many astonishing tales shared on platforms like AskVets.
The PDSA anticipates that the average dog owner will spend at least £5,000 throughout a pet's life, with some estimates reaching a minimum of £12,200 depending on the dog's size. This is the current reality, but inflation is poised to exacerbate these costs due to...
... the alarming trend of veterinary practices being acquired by private equity firms. Similar to human healthcare, these investors are beginning to assert their influence.
Dogs represent a unique asset—decisions about veterinary care or treatments can be quickly overshadowed by the irresistible appeal of a dog's expressive eyes.
The Freakonomics podcast has delved into the rise of private equity in veterinary services. While I won’t elaborate further, it’s evident that dog owners are facing increased financial strain for diminished care:
Do You Still Want a Dog?
The initial expenses of dog ownership are climbing. Considerations such as allergies and breed appeal have pushed prices up to £1,382.41 as of 2022 in the UK.
If you're willing to make the investment, the priciest breeds include the Samoyed ($14,000) or the Tibetan Mastiff, which can cost over $1 million.
This is just the beginning; the dog food market reached $58.45 billion in 2022, surpassing even toilet paper—it's larger than some nations.
Opt for premium dog food, and you could spend $70 weekly, totaling $3,640 annually or a staggering $36,400 over the dog's lifetime. Such expenditures represent a significant opportunity cost.
What Role Do Dogs Play in Our Lives?
Dogs were domesticated due to a mutually beneficial relationship. Whether for security, hunting, or companionship, both species gained from this bond.
In today's world, the role of service dogs—assisting the visually impaired or detecting narcotics—is clear, but this does not apply to the majority of pet dogs.
Most dogs are bred primarily for companionship, serving as emotional support rather than fulfilling a critical need. It’s no wonder that pet ownership is often associated with homelessness, with an estimated 24% of homeless individuals having a pet—dogs offer unconditional acceptance.
Similarly, during the pandemic, dog ownership surged as many turned to pets for comfort amid declining mental health. Their endearing faces provide a sense of solace:
However, there exists a troubling correlation that reflects our growing obsession with dogs.
The term "fur baby" didn't arise randomly; for years, pet ownership has been likened to a simplified version of family life. As parenting becomes increasingly challenging, the allure of a pet as a substitute companion is understandable.
Another statistic highlights the changing dynamics of western society:
We are increasingly living in isolation.
Dogs serve as a connection among the homeless, widows, young couples, and those without families.
They provide comfort in a world where we often fail to support each other, masking the symptoms of a more isolated society.
This Is a Concern... for Dogs
We've all witnessed how a family dog can be neglected when a new baby arrives. This theme is depicted in the classic 1955 film Lady and the Tramp, where the arrival of a child relegates the dog to a lower status.
Similarly, as the pandemic subsides, the demand for at-home companionship has waned.
Dogs are being abandoned in alarming numbers.
Their existence, dictated by the whims of a self-serving species, places them in a precarious situation.
This issue is compounded by the fact that many breeds are specifically engineered for aesthetics, resulting in significant physical health issues. Breeds like the King Charles Spaniel, with their brachycephalic skulls, face immense struggles in a world that can be unforgiving.
Are Dogs Still Truly Dogs?
The definition of a species is often debated. While Charles Darwin deemed it undefinable, Ernst Mayr outlined a common understanding in 1942: for two individuals to belong to the same species, they must be capable of producing viable offspring.
It’s unlikely that a Rottweiler would mate with a Pomeranian, though they may share 98% of their DNA.
Despite sharing a significant amount of genetic material, these breeds are vastly different—neither should exist in such extreme forms.
If the goal had been to maintain farms or source food, less focus on breeding for specific traits could have avoided many of these issues.
Yet here we are, with dogs struggling due to their modified characteristics, whether it be with narrow nasal passages or elongated backs like Dachshunds. If humans were subjected to similar selective breeding, it would read like a horror story.
Furthermore, our obsession with keeping them free of pests has turned them into carriers of biological hazards.
A 2020 study revealed that 99% of UK waterways contained the toxin Fipronil, a byproduct of flea treatments used on pets. The same study also found widespread contamination from the nerve agent imidacloprid.
Popular dog-walking paths are now littered with dead aquatic life, highlighting the absence of invertebrates.
All these factors should prompt reflection. The bond between humans and dogs was once a natural alliance, enhancing both our survival chances—much like sharks and their remoras, or daisies and bees. We had dogs.
Today, our relationship with them reflects our own estrangement from nature, albeit in a more pronounced manner.
The commercialization of the dog industry has been harsh, and it's only growing, making these once-innocent companions increasingly unsustainable, much like ourselves.
