Reconsidering My Stance on Apple Laptops: A Fresh Perspective
Written on
Chapter 1: Initial Reservations
In the past, I've voiced significant concerns regarding Apple's laptop offerings, particularly the soldered storage in every MacBook, including the so-called “Pro” versions. This design choice means that the storage component is permanently affixed to the laptop's motherboard, unlike many traditional PC laptops that allow for modular storage replacement. This creates challenges for users who might need to upgrade their storage or replace a failing drive. For me, this soldered design represents a considerable drawback, especially given that Apple markets its laptops as high-end devices.
But could there be a viable solution? I decided to purchase a MacBook Pro.
I'm aware of the irony; I'm the same person who previously wrote about my frustrations with Mac laptops.
Despite my criticisms, I genuinely believe that Apple's approach to soldered storage undermines consumer choice and contributes to increased electronic waste. However, after struggling with a series of lackluster Windows laptops, I opted for a 14" MacBook Pro.
Section 1.1: Disappointing Experiences with Windows Laptops
I've encountered numerous issues with various Windows laptops, leading to a string of returns. The problems ranged from backlight bleeding, faulty keyboards, inconsistent power-ups, to display defects like dead pixels and uneven screens. These persistent issues have made my laptop search frustrating, as each time I thought I found the right machine, I was met with significant flaws.
Though I recognize that I might be more selective than the average consumer, I believe it's reasonable to expect a well-functioning device when making a substantial investment. Currently, I rely on a Dell XPS 17 9170 for work and gaming; while it performs admirably, its weight makes it cumbersome for daily transport.
Subsection 1.1.1: A New Hope with Apple
With that in mind, I approached Apple with cautious optimism.
Addressing my primary concern regarding soldered storage, I still stand firm in my belief that this design choice is counterproductive and leads to a lack of options for consumers. SSDs do degrade over time, and while it may take years, the reality is that they do wear out. Batteries can be replaced, but storage should also be upgradable.
Interestingly, I discovered a workaround for those worried about storage limitations: booting from an external Thunderbolt SSD. Although this method may be slower than using the internal drive, it provides a viable alternative. Additionally, Apple's built-in Time Machine offers excellent backup solutions, ensuring that files and settings are safe in case of internal drive failures or OS reinstallation.
Section 1.2: The Duality of My Experience
Am I completely sold on soldered storage? Absolutely not. I firmly believe that Apple could easily implement socketed storage if they chose to; any claims to the contrary seem like mere excuses.
That said, given my typical usage, my current 1TB SSD should last for years, as I don’t plan to engage in heavy video editing or extensive storage demands. My primary tasks will involve writing, emails, and light design work in Illustrator.
I maintain strict backup protocols with Time Machine and Google Drive, a prudent practice regardless of the storage type.
Chapter 2: Finding Balance in the Mac Experience
In the video "Here's why I'm officially quitting Apple Laptops," the creator discusses their frustrations with Apple’s design choices, providing insights into why some users feel disillusioned with MacBooks.
In "I've Been Buying The Wrong MacBook Pros," the presenter shares their journey through various MacBook models, highlighting the importance of making informed purchasing decisions.
While I appreciate many aspects of macOS and the MacBook Pro, I remain critical of certain Apple choices. The battery life on my model is outstanding, and the Mini-LED ProMotion display is a significant improvement over the subpar screens seen in many laptops today. The SSD is incredibly fast, apps launch almost instantly, and I love the seamless integration of iMessage on my laptop.
Nevertheless, no system is flawless. Apple could easily design machines with upgradable storage, yet they’ve opted not to do so—at least for this model.
To clarify, my critiques of Apple do not stem from a disdain for their products; quite the opposite. I own several Apple devices, including an iPad Pro, iPhone, and Apple Watch, alongside my new MacBook Pro. My criticisms arise from a desire for Apple to achieve its full potential, benefiting both customers and the company itself.
Will Apple continue to impress me as I use this machine? While I’ve encountered a minor cosmetic issue that might necessitate an exchange, I find the 14" MacBook Pro to be impressive overall. Though I still rely on Windows for most of my work due to software compatibility, I genuinely appreciate several features of the Mac.
As for battery life? Absolutely! I hope PC manufacturers take note of Apple's advancements in this area. The ability to work for extended periods with minimal battery drain is a refreshing change from my previous experiences with Windows laptops.
While I prefer Windows' window management over macOS's approach, this is purely a matter of personal preference, and many users may disagree with my viewpoint.
Only time will tell how my feelings toward Macs will evolve as I continue to use this machine. I will keep a close eye on the SSD's performance and document my experiences, but for now, I must admit: I’m impressed.